The two garage bay doors still hang the way they did when this was a Standard Oil station in 1935. Vintage license plates cover the walls. A pair of decommissioned gas pumps stand watch on the patio, leftovers from a version of Cave Creek that existed before Cave Creek was really a town. For nearly 25 years, the building has worn a different disguise: Big Earl’s Greasy Eats, the burger joint whose milkshakes and grease-and-chrome charm made it a fixture of the local dining scene. That’s about to change again.

A black-and-white photo of two men in white shirts standing beside a pickup truck in front of a Standard Oil station
A vintage view of the Standard Oil station that later became Big Earl’s Greasy Eats.

Kimberly Brennan is the reason both versions exist. She bought the old station in 2002 and spent 15 years turning it into Big Earl’s, the restaurant that introduced a generation of Cave Creek diners to the building’s history. She sold it, swore off restaurants, and went on to open PIEbar AZ, a hand-pie empanada stand in the mountain town of Strawberry that turned into something of a phenomenon — Arizona Highways coverage, viral video traffic, as many as 1,200 empanadas sold on a single day. Now she’s coming back to 6135 E. Cave Creek Road to do it again, this time on her own terms.

A hand holds a golden empanada in front of the yellow-and-black PIEbar sign
A PIEbar AZ empanada at the original stand in Strawberry.

The Cave Creek menu will look familiar to anyone who has made the drive up Highway 87 for the Strawberry original — the Mountain Man, the Mountain Mamma, the rotating seasonal flavors — with a few new additions specific to the new location. But before any empanada gets pressed inside the old station, Brennan says the building itself needs attention.

“The old gas station building has housed Big Earl’s for nearly 25 years,” Brennan says. “With a use that intense for that long, the building needs some serious love if it’s going to keep standing for another hundred years. My first order of business is to restore the vintage building to its former glory.”

Kimberly Brennan leans against a yellow wall on a narrow cobbled street, a shopping bag in her hand
Kimberly Brennan, owner of PIEbar AZ, is returning to Cave Creek to restore the 1935 gas station that once housed her original restaurant, Big Earl’s Greasy Eats.

That work can’t happen with a tenant in place, so Brennan will take back occupancy when Big Earl’s lease ends in January 2027 — and Big Earl’s isn’t disappearing. The restaurant is relocating down the road to Frontier Town, continuing under its own name while Brennan turns her attention to the structure that made it famous in the first place.

“When I sold Big Earl’s, I told myself, ‘I’m done with restaurants,’” she says. “I meant it when I said it, but I guess it gets into your blood.”

It got into hers on a trip that had nothing to do with Cave Creek. She saw a rundown shed in Strawberry — no foundation, no septic system, a crumbling roof — and saw a restaurant in it instead: something fast and handheld that hikers, campers and mountain bikers could stash in a backpack and eat wherever the day took them. No plates, no silverware, just PIEbar.

“Going back to Cave Creek feels like going home,” she says. “There’s no other place like Cave Creek, Arizona. It’s wild — the landscape, the people, the politics. The mountains up north are beautiful, but Cave Creek is magic. I can’t wait.”

Fitting a restaurant into a 90-year-old gas station means working around decisions somebody else made decades ago, and Brennan says that’s a lesson she already learned once.

Aerial view of the red-awninged Big Earl’s Greasy Eats building on Cave Creek Road with a desert mountain behind it
Big Earl’s Greasy Eats on Cave Creek Road, in the 1935 Standard Oil station.

“Unlike a typical buildout, accommodating a restaurant inside an existing gas station means the building shapes you, not the other way around,” she says. “I’ll have to work around the structure itself, honoring it first.”

She’s considering an open kitchen layout, the same setup she uses in Strawberry, so guests can watch the dough get rolled and the empanadas pressed into shape. And she’s setting a standard for the rest of the space, too.

“I like things really, really clean,” she says. “From the bathrooms to the patios to the kitchen and dining areas, PIEbar Cave Creek will be sparkling.”

Brennan talks about the building itself the way a caretaker might — something bigger than any single business that’s occupied it.

“It’s moved between centuries, tying the past to the present and the future,” she says. “Whether as a gas station, a burger joint or a PIEbar, it’s a special piece of American history right in our town. I’m taking on this renovation with all my heart and soul, and I sure hope to make Cave Creek proud.”

Photography Courtesy of Kimberly Brennan

Visit piebaraz.com